TikTok³ÉÈ˰æ

close

Canonsburg mother whose infant daughter died from fentanyl pleads guilty to drug charge

By Mike Jones 3 min read
article image -
Shannon McKnight

The Canonsburg mother whose infant daughter died from fentanyl poisoning in 2022 will serve time in prison after she pleaded guilty to a lesser drug charge Tuesday in a similar plea deal the child’s father accepted last week.

Shannon McKnight cried as she spoke to Judge Valarie Costanzo during her sentencing hearing at the Washington County Courthouse in which she said the death of her 3-month-old daughter, Navaeah, was a “tragic accident.”

“No words can even begin to explain the pain I feel,” McKnight told Costanzo. “My heart is broken. I would do anything to bring my baby daughter back.”

Navaeah died Aug. 11, 2022, after she became unresponsive while sleeping in bed with McKnight and her father, James May IV, inside the couple’s First Street residence. The bedroom was littered with drugs and paraphernalia, and an autopsy revealed the presence of fentanyl in Navaeah’s system at the time of her death. Her 16-month-old brother was also sickened by the drug, but survived.

McKnight, 26, pleaded guilty Tuesday to one felony count of drug delivery resulting in death, and Costanzo immediately sentenced her to serve 10 to 20 years in a state prison as part of the negotiated plea. May, 34, took an identical plea Thursday and was sentenced to the same prison term. Both will be given credit for time served since they’ve been held without bond at the Washington County jail since their arrest a week after Navaeah’s death.

McKnight and May had originally been charged with criminal homicide and were facing the possibility of the death penalty if they had been convicted of first-degree murder. But investigators were unable to determine how the fentanyl entered Navaeah’s body, and the death penalty was eventually removed from consideration and a plea deal was offered.

While McKnight didn’t go as far as May when he theorized during his sentencing Thursday that the infant died from “co-sleeping” with them, she did tell Costanzo that she disagreed with the circumstances surrounding the plea agreement.

“I’ve been going through hell behind these walls,” McKnight said of her time in jail. “We’re not horrible people. We just made bad mistakes.”

McKnight said she hasn’t been able to properly grieve her daughter’s death and has not been offered counseling to deal with the loss, although neither she nor May attended Navaeah’s funeral because they were on the run from authorities at the time. Shortly after Navaeah died at Canonsburg Hospital, police were unable to locate May and McKnight for about a week until they were found at an acquaintance’s Canton Township home, hiding in an attic crawl space.

McKnight was shackled and wearing an orange jail jumpsuit as she sat at the defense table beside her attorney, Chad Schneider, for the hearing that lasted less than 15 minutes. She was then led away by sheriff’s deputies and returned to the Washington County jail before eventually being transferred to a state prison.

CUSTOMER LOGIN

If you have an account and are registered for online access, sign in with your email address and password below.

NEW CUSTOMERS/UNREGISTERED ACCOUNTS

Never been a subscriber and want to subscribe, click the Subscribe button below.

Starting at $4.79/week.